Email Sign-Up Scorecard: Sephora, Hot Topic, Kenneth Cole

Posted on by Beth Negus Viveiros

Building a good list is an essential part of any email marketing program. I tried to sign-up for three marketers' email lists this week, two successfully and one not so much so.

First up was Kenneth Cole, which has a reputation for some very clever email creative. A sign-up button was clearly featured on the top of the home page, and when I clicked a pop-up appeared asking for my email address, gender, birthdate, zip code and mobile phone number, so they could send me text messages.

But…I don't want text messages. I want emails. I click the submit button without providing my mobile number, to find out that this is part of the mandatory information needed to get on their email list. There is a short code provided that I can respond to once I give them my mobile number to opt out of texts–but why the heck to I have to opt in to receive them in the first place, when all I want to receive are emails?

I'll pass, thanks. This just isn't a good way to start a relationship.

Sephora, in contrast, is a lot more fun. The first thing I see on their home page is an opportunity to win "Today's Big Thrill," which is 365 bottles of nail polish. Now, I need 365 bottles of nail polish like I need another hole in my head. But do I want them? Heck yeah, I do!

I give my email to enter the contest and am taken to another screen to give additional information and opt-in to their email list if I choose. I do, and almost immediately receive a welcome email confirming my contest entry.

Hot Topic also quickly sent a welcome email when I signed up for their list. I click on the "Get Email" button on the home page, and I'm offered two options. One is to simply sign up for the list, and the other is to create a HT+1 account and join their loyalty program.

I opt for the latter, and fill in my information (mobile number is requested but not mandatory, and there's an opt-in option for receiving texts). When the process is complete, I'm taken to a profile page where members can upload a photo, or share things like their favorite music or brands, should they want to share a public profile with site users.

What email lists have you signed up for (or thought better and decided not to join) lately? Let me know at


Related Posts

Chief Marketer Videos

by Patty Odell

This campaign, Netflix at AsiaPOP Comicon from Jack Morton Worldwide, landed a 2019 Gold PRO Award.


PRO Awards